Restaurant CPA in Toronto who explains what the numbers are doing
A restaurant CPA in Toronto and the GTA. Monthly books that handle tips, the $4 HST rebate and food cost, so you can see what last month made.
The till shows what came in last night. The monthly picture takes more putting together: what the restaurant made last month, how the cash moved, and how payroll and the next HST payment line up with the bank balance.
Rundle is a CPA firm in Mississauga, Ontario, and a restaurant accountant for owners in Toronto, across the Greater Toronto Area and in the rest of Ontario. That includes cafes and other food service businesses. I keep the books, look after payroll and HST, and prepare your corporate tax return (the T2). Each month you can see what the restaurant earned and why it changed.
A few things make restaurant books harder to get right. Tips that aren't your money pass through your bank account, an HST rule turns on whether an order came to more than $4, and food costs move every week. Handled correctly, they give you numbers you can rely on when you decide on prices, staffing or a new lease.
To start, send a short note about the restaurant. A 20-minute call can follow if it helps.
Which tips go through your payroll?
When you pay staff, you deduct Canada Pension Plan (CPP) contributions, Employment Insurance (EI) premiums and income tax and send them to CRA. CRA splits tips into two kinds, controlled and direct, and the kind decides whether tips go through your payroll and onto the T4 slip (the form showing each employee's pay for the year). Either way, tips are taxable income to the employee.
Controlled tips
Controlled tips are tips where you decide the amount or who gets it, or that you hold before your staff get them. A mandatory service charge and a percentage added to the bill are both controlled. So are tips that land in your bank account and are paid out later, a tip pool you set up, and a tip-out formula you designed. You deduct CPP, EI and income tax on controlled tips and report them on the employee's T4.
Direct tips
Direct tips go from the customer to the employee without you controlling the amount or who gets it. Cash left on the table, a tip handed straight to a server, a pool the staff set up themselves, and a card tip you pass back in full, in cash, are all direct. You withhold nothing on direct tips, and they don't go on the T4. The employee reports them on their own tax return and can choose to pay CPP on them. If you've read about "declared tips", that's a Quebec rule and doesn't apply in Ontario.
Tip-outs and house pools
A tip-out that management designed, or a pool the house runs, can look like direct tips. Under CRA's test both are controlled, so CPP and EI are owed on them, and any shortfall adds up with each pay period. I can look at how tips are shared in your restaurant and help make sure payroll treats them accordingly.
When does the $4 prepared food rebate apply?
HST in Ontario is 13%, made up of 5% federal and 8% provincial. On qualifying prepared food and drinks, Ontario rebates the provincial 8% when their total, before HST, is not more than $4.00, so those sales are taxed at 5% at the till. The $4 limit hasn't changed since 2010, so as menu prices rise, fewer orders fall under it.
Most of a quick-service menu qualifies. The items that count on their own are:
- hot food and drinks, meaning anything heated for consumption
- sandwiches that aren't frozen
- salads that aren't canned or vacuum sealed
- cold cut, fruit or vegetable platters
- single-serving baked goods that aren't prepackaged, sold in quantities under six
- single servings of ice cream or frozen yoghurt that aren't prepackaged
- non-carbonated drinks poured on site
- milk, and soy, rice or almond drinks
- non-carbonated juice drinks that are at least 25% natural juice
Carbonated drinks poured on site, other drinks sold in single-serving containers, prepackaged baked goods sold in quantities under six and snack foods qualify only when they're sold with one of those items. Alcohol never qualifies.
Two details are worth knowing. Items that don't qualify are ignored when you work out whether the order is within $4. And going over $4 loses the rebate on the whole qualifying total, not only the amount above it. A $3.95 coffee and pastry is taxed at 5%, but if the qualifying items come to twenty cents more, all of it is taxed at 13%.
Your point of sale system applies the rebate, and its settings are up to you or your provider. A wrong setting can make the HST wrong on many sales, so it's worth rechecking the settings whenever menu prices change. When you tell me prices have changed, I can check the HST in your sales records against the $4 rule so a setup error can show up early.
The temporary federal GST/HST break on restaurant meals ran from 14 December 2024 to 15 February 2025 and has ended, so anything still saying restaurant meals are tax-free is out of date.
How should a restaurant measure food cost?
Food cost percentage tells you how much of your food sales went on the food itself: your cost of goods sold (what the food you sold cost you) divided by food sales. It only means something when it's measured from what you used, which needs an inventory count at the start and end of each period.
Your kitchen does the count, and I can use it to work out a food cost percentage you can act on. When it climbs, you can then see whether prices went up, portions grew or more food was thrown out.
The monthly numbers I prepare show food, beverage and labour on separate lines, because what you keep from each dollar differs sharply between food and beverage. Labour is worth watching as a share of sales each week. Prime cost, meaning food and labour together, is the figure to watch most closely, because those are usually the largest costs you can control.
Inventory at year end
For tax, the food in your walk-in is inventory, the same as a shop's retail stock. The value of food on hand at the start of the year (your opening inventory) must equal the value recorded at the end of last year. A wrong count at one year end therefore carries into the next year's cost of goods and the profit you're taxed on. You also have to value inventory the same way each year unless CRA agrees to a change. I use your year-end count in preparing the corporate tax return and check that it lines up with last year's figure.
Payroll, HST filing and the build-out
Payroll and staff turnover
When an employee's pay stops, for example because they leave, you issue a record of employment (ROE), the form they need to apply for Employment Insurance. Staff changes are a normal part of food service, so ROEs go out regularly, and I prepare them as part of payroll. How often you send payroll deductions to CRA depends mainly on how much you withheld two calendar years earlier. That schedule can change as the restaurant grows, and the payment dates change with it. I confirm which one applies each year and prepare the payments to match.
How often you file HST
Where CRA lets you choose, filing HST more often means smaller payments, which can be easier to set aside than one annual balance. I prepare the HST return on whichever schedule applies and can talk through whether a shorter one would suit your cash flow.
The build-out
The cost of building out a leased space (the construction and finishing work done to the unit itself) counts as a leasehold improvement for tax. You don't deduct it all in the year you spend it. Instead, you deduct it in equal amounts over the lease term plus the first renewal option, if there is one, and over no fewer than five years. Past five years, a longer lease means a smaller deduction each year, which is worth knowing when you compare lease terms.
How I work with restaurants
If your restaurant has no finance person, I can be that person. Each month you get numbers that show what the restaurant earned, and someone to talk a price change or a new hire through with before you commit.
Monthly accounting is where most of the work sits. Each month I record sales, purchases and payroll, check the books against your bank and card statements, and prepare payroll remittances and HST returns as they fall due. When profit moves, you can see which cost moved it while there's still time to act.
Tax planning covers how you pay yourself from the corporation, through salary, dividends or a mix, and we settle that together during the year while the choice can still change your tax. At year end I prepare your corporate tax return (T2) from the same books you've been seeing all year.
Opening a second location or renegotiating a lease is a business advisory question, and I can work through what it would mean for your cash and profit before you sign.
Send a short note describing the restaurant, how tips are shared and who keeps the books now. I aim to reply the same business day, and a 20-minute call can follow if it helps.
Send a short noteor call or text 416-450-7981
Common questions about tips, HST and food cost in restaurants
Do I have to deduct CPP and EI on tips?
You have to deduct CPP and EI on controlled tips, the ones you decide how to share or hold first. That includes a service charge, a house pool, your own tip-out formula and tips you bank and pay out later. Direct tips, where you have no control, carry no deductions and don't go on the T4.
Why does my food cost percentage keep moving?
Food cost percentage often keeps moving because it's calculated from purchases rather than from what you used. Counting inventory at the start and end of each period brings waste, spoilage, over-portioning and theft into view.
Can I deduct meals I eat at my own restaurant?
Meals you eat yourself at your own restaurant are personal and not deductible. The food and drink you sell is cost of goods sold, a full business expense. Business meals and entertainment are normally only 50% deductible, but that limit doesn't apply to food and drink you sell, because selling it is your business.
Should my restaurant file HST monthly or annually?
How often a restaurant files HST is set by CRA from its taxable sales. Above $6,000,000 in taxable sales you must file monthly, and below that CRA usually assigns quarterly or annual filing, which you can choose to shorten.
Do you work with restaurants outside Toronto?
Rundle works with restaurants in Toronto, Mississauga, across the Greater Toronto Area and in the rest of Ontario. The work runs in cloud software and over video, so nobody needs to visit an office.
Written by Rundle Accounting & Advisory, a CPA firm in Mississauga. About the firm. Last reviewed: 14 September 2026.
This page is general information about Canadian tax rules, not advice for your situation. Thresholds and rules change, and how they apply depends on your own operation.